GWS stay snugly in the eight with first win over Richmond at the MCG

We’re sorry, this feature is currently unavailable. We’re working to restore it. Please try again later.

Advertisement

GWS stay snugly in the eight with first win over Richmond at the MCG

Loading

Key posts

Pinned post from

Key points Giants defeat Tigers

By Peter Ryan

Toby Greene the difference, again

Toby was the difference in the contest with his four goals just one indicator of the influence he had on the result.

In the third quarter, as the Tigers strived to stay in touch, the brilliant Greene just turned half chances into goals.

The first moment came as he grabbed a loose ball at half-forward and was tackled. Somehow he managed to turn his body and shuffle a handball to Toby Bedford who kicked a goal. A moment later he gained the ball in a chain of handballs and kicked a perfectly weighted kick to Jake Riccardi.

Toby Greene handballs.

Toby Greene handballs.Credit: via Getty Images

All of a sudden the margin was beyond Richmond’s reach. The natural agitator was then unlucky to not win a downfield free kick with the umpire instead giving the ball to Jesse Hogan.

The only concern for Greene is another potential fine after he shoved his hand into Nathan Broad’s face after outmarking him. The umpire reversed the decision.

Potential dangerous tackle issue for Giant

Tim Taranto left the field in a groggy state in the final quarter after his head crashed into what was once described as the hard centre wicket area in the middle of the MCG.

He fell forward after the man who ran with him throughout, Toby Bedford, chased him down to tackle him. Bedford did not sling him, or drive him into the ground intentionally but it was his momentum that saw the tough Tiger’s head hit the ground so hard.

This will be a tough decision for the MRO to make due to the lack of intent from the Giants player but with the focus on protecting players’ heads, it’s hard to see him escape without penalty, regardless of whether it’s fair to Bedford.

The missing Tiger and the missing Tiger fans

Too often the absence of Dion Prestia is overlooked when any assessment of the Tigers’ fortunes this season. The star on-baller was arguably the second most important driver in Richmond’s engine room (behind Dustin Martin) in the premiership era when huge crowds turned up every week to watch Richmond.

They didn’t on Sunday with just 19,040 spectators, the smallest crowd Richmond had attracted to the MCG since round 12, 2004 when they played Fremantle.

Tim Taranto of the Tigers is helped from the ground.

Tim Taranto of the Tigers is helped from the ground.Credit: via Getty Images

One who did turn up was Prestia for his seventh game of the season. His inclusion meant it was the first time since round two that he had played alongside Tim Taranto, Jacob Hopper and the tireless and brave Toby Nankervis in 2024 and it made the Tigers more competitive.

The trio combined to get the ball forward for the first goal of the match and were good in the contest throughout, ensuring the Tigers led the inside 50 count.

At 31, he showed he can still have a huge influence in the twilight of his career if the Tigers can keep him fit. He finished with 27 disposals, four clearances and six contested possessions. His teammates walk taller when he plays.

Latest posts

Goodnight

Well, that’s all from us tonight, folks.

Thanks for joining us and we’ll catch you next weekend for round 19. Yikes.

Have a good week!

Key points Giants defeat Tigers

By Peter Ryan

Toby Greene the difference, again

Toby was the difference in the contest with his four goals just one indicator of the influence he had on the result.

In the third quarter, as the Tigers strived to stay in touch, the brilliant Greene just turned half chances into goals.

The first moment came as he grabbed a loose ball at half-forward and was tackled. Somehow he managed to turn his body and shuffle a handball to Toby Bedford who kicked a goal. A moment later he gained the ball in a chain of handballs and kicked a perfectly weighted kick to Jake Riccardi.

Toby Greene handballs.

Toby Greene handballs.Credit: via Getty Images

All of a sudden the margin was beyond Richmond’s reach. The natural agitator was then unlucky to not win a downfield free kick with the umpire instead giving the ball to Jesse Hogan.

The only concern for Greene is another potential fine after he shoved his hand into Nathan Broad’s face after outmarking him. The umpire reversed the decision.

Potential dangerous tackle issue for Giant

Tim Taranto left the field in a groggy state in the final quarter after his head crashed into what was once described as the hard centre wicket area in the middle of the MCG.

He fell forward after the man who ran with him throughout, Toby Bedford, chased him down to tackle him. Bedford did not sling him, or drive him into the ground intentionally but it was his momentum that saw the tough Tiger’s head hit the ground so hard.

This will be a tough decision for the MRO to make due to the lack of intent from the Giants player but with the focus on protecting players’ heads, it’s hard to see him escape without penalty, regardless of whether it’s fair to Bedford.

The missing Tiger and the missing Tiger fans

Too often the absence of Dion Prestia is overlooked when any assessment of the Tigers’ fortunes this season. The star on-baller was arguably the second most important driver in Richmond’s engine room (behind Dustin Martin) in the premiership era when huge crowds turned up every week to watch Richmond.

They didn’t on Sunday with just 19,040 spectators, the smallest crowd Richmond had attracted to the MCG since round 12, 2004 when they played Fremantle.

Tim Taranto of the Tigers is helped from the ground.

Tim Taranto of the Tigers is helped from the ground.Credit: via Getty Images

One who did turn up was Prestia for his seventh game of the season. His inclusion meant it was the first time since round two that he had played alongside Tim Taranto, Jacob Hopper and the tireless and brave Toby Nankervis in 2024 and it made the Tigers more competitive.

The trio combined to get the ball forward for the first goal of the match and were good in the contest throughout, ensuring the Tigers led the inside 50 count.

At 31, he showed he can still have a huge influence in the twilight of his career if the Tigers can keep him fit. He finished with 27 disposals, four clearances and six contested possessions. His teammates walk taller when he plays.

Giants stay in the eight

GWS have defeated Richmond for the first time at the MCG with their highest score ever at the hallowed turf. The 24-point win keeps them in the top eight, nice and snugly at 6th spot.

The Tigers got a late consolidation goal from Shai Bolton but the game was well out of their reach by then.

Jesse Hogan and Toby Greene both finished the day with four goals each, while Tom Green had 37 disposals, just ahead of Lachie Whitfield with 35.

GWS defeat Richmond 17.6 (108) to 12.12 (84).

GWS defeat Richmond at the MCG.

GWS defeat Richmond at the MCG.Credit: AFL Photos via Getty Images

Advertisement

GWS with their highest score at the MCG

Kieran Briggs has sealed the win for the Giants, and with the goal, brought GWS to their highest score at the MCG with 108 points.

The game is now out of reach of the Tigers, but their opposition holding a five goal lead with just over two minutes today.

Despite that, Adam Kingsley looks as series as ever on the sidelines.

Giants by 30

Ward stops Tigers’ spark

Callan Ward has kicked an important goal for the Giants after taking a huge intercept mark from a kick out of the Tigers’ defence.

The ball sailed way over the big sticks, but both umpires (along with Toby Greene) convinced it was a goal.

It gives GWS a very handy 25-point lead, with just over five minutes to go.

GWS by 25

Small crowd, but full of voice

By Peter Ryan

Crowd of 19,040 at the MCG today, so only the diehards here.

It’s a long way from the packed house for the 2017 qualifying final.

Quick glance at the stats but by my reading that is the lowest crowd at the MCG (excluding the pandemic years in 2020-21) since Melbourne played the Suns in 2014.

And for Richmond, it’s the lowest crowd the Tigers have drawn to the MCG since round 12, 2004.

Advertisement

Tigers fan spark alive

By Peter Ryan

Two quick goals to Steely Green has put the Tigers back to within 19 points of the Giants. They couldn’t, could they?

All of sudden Richmond supporters are awake. If England can win from nowhere in the Euros, surely Richmond can.

(Note to reader: England are yet to play Spain in the final).

Tigers start a comeback

Well, isn’t that some nerves of Steely Green.

The young Tiger has kicked gone back-to-back in the third term to put Richmond back within four kicks, with 16 minutes left on the clock.

Green has now kicked three goals in his third game in the big time, all three from set shots from big marks deep in the inside 50. He makes a good target with contested grabs like that.

Giants by 19

Tartano comes off after dangerous tackle

Important Tigers star Tim Taranto has come from the ground after his head hit the ground with force. The tackle came from Giant Toby Bedford, who will now wait to see if he’s cited by the MRO.

Commentary on Fox all agree the incident will certainly be looked at by the Match Review Officer.

Meanwhile, Giants midfielder Stephen Coniglio subbed off with shoulder soreness and replaced by James Peatling.

Peter Ryan on the Bedford tackle:

A nasty head knock for the Tigers’ Tim Taranto as he crashed into the turf when tackled by Toby Bedford. It will be examined by the MRO despite the fact he was chasing Taranto hard and ran him down.

Advertisement

Rioli scores off half-back

Jesse Hogan opened the final term with his fourth goal of the day, to put the game further out of the grasp of the Tigers.

Hogan’s goal came from a stoppage scoring chain, the Giants’ 6th from that source today.

But keeping the spirit alive for Richmond is Dan Rioli, who had a classy finish with a goal off half-back.

Giants by 31

Most Viewed in Sport

Loading