Luca is a teacher in a skills crisis, but his HIV means he’s not allowed to stay
A migrant teacher denied permanent residency because he has been diagnosed with HIV says he has been barred by a discriminatory policy overseen by the government during a national skills crisis.
Italian national Luca, who has chosen a pseudonym because of the stigma associated with his condition, has been stuck in a limbo of temporary visas after he was refused a permanent skilled visa in 2013, with Immigration Minister Andrew Giles powerless to intervene.
Italian-born teacher Luca has been denied a permanent residency visa because he has been diagnosed with HIV.Credit: Eddie Jim
“We hear it on the news every day there is a shortage of teachers and nurses,” said Luca, who teaches languages at a Melbourne high school, adding he often received job offers because of the dire need for teachers across the nation.
“Things have changed since I was first diagnosed … the stigma is not as strong as it used to be. I’m as healthy as I’ve ever been.”
The government can bar migrants from settling in Australia if their health requirements are deemed to be too costly for the public purse, a system that has led to many families with disabled children being told they must leave the country.
Welcoming Disability migration policy adviser Dr Jan Gothard said it was common for migrants to fail the health requirement for being HIV positive. “People who take HIV medication can undertake any work except some specialised medical procedures,” she said.
“They’re no less productive than any other member of the community. It doesn’t make any sense.”
Giles last year ordered a review into the significant cost threshold, the mechanism, currently set to $51,000 over 10 years, that determines if a visa applicant’s needs are too burdensome for the community.
“The minister retains the powers to intervene in cases where there are compassionate and compelling reasons for someone to be granted a visa,” a spokesperson for his office told this masthead when asked about Luca’s case.
But an email to Luca from Home Affairs in September last year said Giles had no power to intervene after that opportunity had been exhausted under the previous government in May 2017, when former assistant immigration minister Alex Hawke determined it wasn’t in the public interest to step in.
Hawke’s refusal came three years after the former Migration Review Tribunal found that Luca possessed skills that would benefit the Australian community but decided not to overturn the government’s decision to bar him from gaining permanency because of his HIV status.
After Hawke refused to intervene Luca was given three weeks to leave the country, before his employer appealed to the then-government to allow him to stay. He was granted a special visa with temporary working rights, before switching to a partner visa with his New Zealand partner.
However, Luca questioned whether he could stay in the country permanently on a temporary basis when he is allowed to reapply next year. “This is a difficult question because it has taken a toll,” he said. “I spent the whole of my 30s with this thing on the back of my mind. I wasn’t able to see my family for many years, not able to settle down and buy a house. I’m running out of options.”
Greens immigration spokesman David Shoebridge said Luca’s was a clear case where Home Affairs’ attitudes and policies had failed to take into account changing community sentiment and advances in medical treatment.
“In 2024, an HIV diagnosis should not be a reason for Home Affairs to refuse permanent residency in Australia,” he said. “We need a federal government that fights this kind of misinformed stigma on HIV, not one that reinforces it.”
Cut through the noise of federal politics with news, views and expert analysis. Subscribers can sign up to our weekly Inside Politics newsletter.